By John E. Hayes and Cara Exten, Penn State
Updated: Thu, 24 Dec 2020 11:54:02 GMT
Source: The Conversation
Editor's Note: The views expressed in this commentary are solely those of the writers. CNN is showcasing the work of The Conversation, a collaboration between journalists and academics to provide news analysis and commentary. The content is produced solely by The Conversation.
Smell loss -- called anosmia -- is a common symptom of Covid-19. For the past nine months, the two of us -- a sensory scientist and an infectious disease epidemiologist -- have applied our respective expertise to develop smell-based screening and testing programs as part of a response to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic.
In early October, one of our graduate students shared the story of her mom and her daily coffee routine. It illustrates perfectly how smell checks could be used as a screening tool for Covid-19 infection. One afternoon, our graduate student's mom went to make her habitual cup of coffee only to discover she could not smell or taste it. She'd heard from her daughter about Covid-associated anosmia, so she next tried smelling some pine-scented cleaning spray and couldn't smell that either.
Given her sudden and unexplained anosmia, our student's mom quarantined herself and got a Covid-19 test, which came back positive. By taking her smell loss seriously, getting a rapid test and self-isolating, she created a dead end for the virus, breaking the transmission chain before the virus could spread to anyone else.
By some estimates, 44% to 77% of people with Covid-19 lose their sense of smell. But many are unaware they have lost their sense of smell until they actively try to smell something that should have an odor, like scented candles. This is why we are encouraging people to actively try to smell something each day. Sudden unexplained anosmia is a specific symptom of Covid-19. It can be used as a daily DIY screening tool by individuals, providing another tool in the fight to contain Covid-19.
READ MORE: Rapid COVID-19 tests can be useful -- but there are far too few to put a dent in the pandemic
A smell stopper
Covid-19 affects your sense of smell in a different way than a common cold does. When your nose is stuffy, odorants -- the lightweight odor active molecules found in the air -- are physically unable to reach the smell receptors at the top of your nasal cavity.
With Covid-19, loss of smell is instead caused by a signaling disruption. Research has shown that the virus attacks cells behind the bridge of the nose immediately next to olfactory neurons. These supporting cells are covered with many of the ACE2 receptors that the virus exploits to enter cells, so they are especially vulnerable. This tissue becomes inflamed, temporarily disrupting the ability of the olfactory neurons to signal the presence of an odorant.
Unlike the common cold, many Covid-19 patients also lose their sense of taste as well as chemesthesis -- the ability to sense the tingle of carbonation or burn of chili peppers.
READ MORE: How the first FDA-approved at-home test works
A very specific symptom
Unexplained anosmia is normally quite rare with other viral infections, especially in the absence of congestion or nasal blockage. If someone loses their sense of smell that is a good sign of a possible Covid-19 infection. In fact, recent analyses suggest that if you had to pick just one symptom, sudden smell loss may be the single best predictor of a Covid-19 diagnosis.
Loss of smell is very specific to Covid-19, but not everyone with SARS-CoV-2 infection reports smell loss. Critically, being able to smell things does not mean you are Covid-free. If you were able to smell your coffee this morning, that is an ambiguous result: It might mean you don't have Covid-19, but it could also mean that you are infected with SARS-CoV-2 and simply didn't lose your normal sense of smell.
While fever checks have been widely deployed, they are not specific to Covid-19 -- many other illnesses, like the flu or strep throat, also cause fevers. Using loss of smell as a Covid-19 test is far from perfect. But because a daily smell check is very specific, instantaneous and quite literally free, it is a highly useful screening tool.
READ MORE: Covid-19 immunity and reinfection: why it's still essential to take precautions
Do it yourself, daily
The story of our graduate student's mom illustrates how active smell checks can catch Covid-19 cases in people with no other symptoms. At Penn State, where we work, we are putting this into action.
This fall, the school launched our "Stop. Smell. Be well" project to raise awareness of the connection between sudden smell loss and Covid-19. We even developed different "sniff cards" with a peel-and-smell panel so people could check their sense of smell with a standardized tool.
While such a tool is preferable for research, doing a daily smell test for public health reasons does not require a bespoke sniff card. The test could be simply sniffing your morning cup of coffee or the shampoo you use in the shower.
Smell checks cannot and will not catch every undiagnosed infection, since an estimated quarter to half of Covid-19 patients do not lose their sense of smell. But given that DIY smell tests can be done at zero cost, the downsides of using them for screening are minimal.
READ MORE: Coronavirus vaccines: how will we know when life can go back to normal?
Screening stops spread
Screening is one of the most basic tools of public health. The most critical factors for an effective Covid-19 screening tool are frequency and speed, with test sensitivity being secondary.
It is easy to check your sense of smell -- who doesn't have a bag of coffee or tea in their kitchen or a bar of soap in the bathroom? And it is fast -- you know immediately if your milk went sour. Combine this with the high specificity of anosmia relative to other symptoms, and we believe daily at-home smell checks can help fill the need for a rapid, cheap and specific screening tool. Tracking sudden smell loss can even be used for population-level monitoring of Covid-19 cases within a country or region.
Of course, no screening program will catch 100% of cases. It is critical for individuals to continue practicing other harm reduction behaviors. Still, we encourage you to Stop. Smell. Be well. And if you do lose your sense of smell, please self-isolate and contact a health professional.